✕
shopping cart
prev
Ever wondering if we carry ANY back stock of your FAVORITE flavors? Those quick, limited edition flavors that you wish you would have bought more of and you are now kicking yourself you didn't? Well, here is your chance to score another jar.
Every couple of weeks we will throw up Mystery Jars. These are all our HOTTEST, MOST SOUGHT flavors we carry. They are limited edition flavors that we don't have a enough stock of to do a full restock, but we WANT you to try and get your hands on them. Mystery Jars will be grabbed 100% randomly.
3/23/25 LINE UP:
Bananas Foster Cheesecake
Banoffee Pie
Better Than Anything Brownie
Blackberry Cake
Blue Mint
Brownie Fudge Cheesecake
Cake Batter Crunch
Cake Batter Fudge
Cali Chiffon
Caramel Apple Empanada
Caramel & Cookie Twist
Caramel Truffle Sundae
Chantilly Cake
Cherry Custard
Chocolate Hazelnut
Churro Bundt Cake
Coco-Nutty Cookie
Confetti Banana Pudding
Cookie Butter Brownie Cheesecake
Cookie Butter Berry Cheesecake
Cookie Cake
Cookie Nom-ster Cheesecake
Cookie Skillet
Cookies & Cream Cake Batter
Corn Palace Muffin
Crunchy Dragon
Dark Choc Raspberry Truffle
Dough Leche New Tella
Fried Ice Cream
Frosted Brookie
Gateaux Cupcake
German Toffee Cheesecake
Ghosted
Hummingbird Cake
King Cake
Lemon Sugar Cookie
Love Struck
Maple Bar
Momma’s Mint
Nana & New-Tella Sundae
No Bake Cookie
Oatmeal Frosted Pie
Peanut Brittle
Post Caramelone Cookie
Pot O’ Gold
Roca Toffee
S’mores Pup Chow
Salted Caramel Cheesecake
Scotcharoo
Shamrock
Snickerdoodle
Strawberry Cookie Cake
Super Brownie Sundae
Texas Sheet Cake
The Breakup
Turtle Cheesecake
Valentine’s Cake
**There will be NO returns/exchanges on Mystery Jars. Nerdy Nuts takes zero responsibility for allergens or dietary restrictions. Purchasing this product you understand that this is 100% randomly picked and packed. We cannot guarantee you won't get the same flavor if you purchase more than one.** *Images are shot in a temperature control environment. Product will shift/sink in transit and can melt when shipped to warm climates.
Ever wondering if we carry ANY back stock of your FAVORITE flavors? Those quick, limited edition flavors that you wish you would have bought more of and you are now kicking yourself you didn't? Well, here is your chance to score another jar.
Every couple of weeks we will throw up Mystery Jars. These are all our HOTTEST, MOST SOUGHT flavors we carry. They are limited edition flavors that we don't have a enough stock of to do a full restock, but we WANT you to try and get your hands on them. Mystery Jars will be grabbed 100% randomly.
3/23/25 LINE UP:
Bananas Foster Cheesecake
Banoffee Pie
Better Than Anything Brownie
Blackberry Cake
Blue Mint
Brownie Fudge Cheesecake
Cake Batter Crunch
Cake Batter Fudge
Cali Chiffon
Caramel Apple Empanada
Caramel & Cookie Twist
Caramel Truffle Sundae
Chantilly Cake
Cherry Custard
Chocolate Hazelnut
Churro Bundt Cake
Coco-Nutty Cookie
Confetti Banana Pudding
Cookie Butter Brownie Cheesecake
Cookie Butter Berry Cheesecake
Cookie Cake
Cookie Nom-ster Cheesecake
Cookie Skillet
Cookies & Cream Cake Batter
Corn Palace Muffin
Crunchy Dragon
Dark Choc Raspberry Truffle
Dough Leche New Tella
Fried Ice Cream
Frosted Brookie
Gateaux Cupcake
German Toffee Cheesecake
Ghosted
Hummingbird Cake
King Cake
Lemon Sugar Cookie
Love Struck
Maple Bar
Momma’s Mint
Nana & New-Tella Sundae
No Bake Cookie
Oatmeal Frosted Pie
Peanut Brittle
Post Caramelone Cookie
Pot O’ Gold
Roca Toffee
S’mores Pup Chow
Salted Caramel Cheesecake
Scotcharoo
Shamrock
Snickerdoodle
Strawberry Cookie Cake
Super Brownie Sundae
Texas Sheet Cake
The Breakup
Turtle Cheesecake
Valentine’s Cake
**There will be NO returns/exchanges on Mystery Jars. Nerdy Nuts takes zero responsibility for allergens or dietary restrictions. Purchasing this product you understand that this is 100% randomly picked and packed. We cannot guarantee you won't get the same flavor if you purchase more than one.** *Images are shot in a temperature control environment. Product will shift/sink in transit and can melt when shipped to warm climates.
prev
