If you’d like to be notified about new products, news and events – signup for our newsletter below!


Follow us

Find Out About Our New Flavors First!

Subscribe to our Newsletter to be the first to hear about our newest flavor fusions!




(8 customer reviews)

Created by accident but has now become a fan favorite. Tiny slivers of buttered toffee mixed in with the sweet and salty honey roasted peanuts, this spread is devoured most commonly with a spoon. Even though we prefer it with fresh fruit, this thick peanut butter is like eating candy, but being able to get away with it because it’s breakfast.

SKU: 3800 Category:

In stock


Additional information

Weight 16 oz
Dimensions 4 × 4 × 5 in

8 reviews for Toffee

  1. Sarah stein

    Oh my gosh! I ordered the honey roasted, toffee, mocha and white chocolate peanut butters for the second time and They are all incredible! So impressed with the quality and flavors. Highly recommend!

  2. Misty Geffre

    Best peanut butter ever! The texture and flavor is amazing! We make sure we never run out of peanut butter in our house

  3. Becky kueffler

    THe toffee is by far my FAVORITE! I’ve been known to eat it right out of the Jar!

  4. Brooke

    This pb is sooooo good. Love the Toffee flavor combined woth such great pb. Love! Love! Love!

  5. Cori

    I just recently tRied this flavor and now im hooked! Sooo good on toast and To bake with!!

  6. ConnieO. (verified owner)

    Delicious eating it with a spoon out of the jar or spreading it on bananas and apples. Our 5 year old granddaughter loves it on her fruit in the morning. The creativity of this product is unsurpassed. Great product, Great company too. Our first order was misplaced(probably by USPS) and they immediately made a second batch for us and shipped it.

  7. Lindsay

    Fairly certain this has some addictive suBstance included! BY far, the BEST peanut bUtter i’ve ever had. I eat it by the spoonfUl because it’s too good to sharE with a piece of bread.


    I think this one might be my favorite! Delicious and a great crunch! We love it to dip our apples in it!

Add a review

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *